[Question #12095] Hiv risk- condom broke

Avatar photo
10 months ago
Hi,
I was having sex with a sex worker and when i inserted my penis into her anus the condom broke and I immediately pulled out. She said she was hiv negative. Should i consider PEP or not worry at all?
Avatar photo
Edward W. Hook M.D.
10 months ago
Welcome to our Forum.  Thanks for your questions.   I’ll be glad to comment.  If you were in my clinic, without knowing more I would not be recommending PrEP.  Here are the reasons why:

1.  Most commercial sex workers do not have HIV or other STIs.  While there is a range with some being lower risk, most CSWs, and particularly those who work through web sites or brothels, test regularly and take precautions to avoid infection.  Less than 1% of CSWs in North America have HIV.
2.  The risk of acquiring an STI varies with different STIs but the likelihood of transmitting any STI by an infected woman is never higher than 1 in 10-20 for STIs like gonorrhea and for HIV, on average fewer than 1 in 2000 exposures to an untreated infected partner results in infection ( I.e. in the unlikely situation that she had untreated HIV chances are more that 99.95% that you would NOT become infected.
3.  Your exposure was quite brief.  Logically the shorter the exposure, the lower the risk.
4.  She said she was negative.  Most people tell the truth.

You may wish to get tested.  Testing for gonorrhea and chlamydia can be conclusively tested for at any time more than 3-4 days after your exposure.  Testing for syphilis and HIV will take longer to provide conclusive results- 6 weeks but your risk for these infections is also much, much lower as well.

Odds are VERY high that you were not infected.  I hope that the information I’ve provided is helpful.  EWH
---
Avatar photo
Edward W. Hook M.D.
10 months ago
Sorry. My first student would have said that if I saw you in my clinic, I would have tried hard to convince you that you did not need PEP ( not PrEP).   In fact, your risk is so low that I personally would not be willing to prescribe a medication. EWH.---
Avatar photo
10 months ago
Thank you for the clarification doctor. Based on your response, would you recommend just routine testing and moving on with my life and not losing sleep over it? I’ve had intercourse with a sexual provider before and never tested positive for anything.
Avatar photo
Edward W. Hook M.D.
10 months ago
Your past history with this partner adds reassurance to the low risk nature of this encounter.  I’d move forward and not worry.  EWH---