[Question #12159] Question about needle prick
9 months ago
|
Obviously I have severe OCD, especially HIV related. I know my mind is wrecking my life and it has been hard to get a good therapist that you really connect with, without long wait lists and so on. But,in the meantime let me ask a simple question: if I were to be poked with a HIV contaminated needle in a public setting, would I know that? Firstly, would I feel the needle going into my skin ( let's say my arm), would there be visible blood, and would it take longer than a second of a prick to actually infect someone? What I am trying to say is: would it be impossible to get infected if you are poked for a literally a second, not enough to feel it, or see an actual person doing it to you? I just want to get rid of this thought, please help.
9 months ago
|
Just to add in case I was not clear: I DECIDED that somebody poked me with a needle in a mall; I did not feel anything, I did not see anybody doing it to me, and when I came home I saw I had a couple of tiny red dots on my arm, but I think I always have them, just normal variations of dry 63 old women's skin. None of it looked like I was seriously poked by a needle, and again, I did not feel anything, nothing. It is just that a horrible thought came to me and I cannot get rid of it. Again, the question is: if something that's serious happened, where a person could actually be infected, that person would know and feel, right? Thank you very much. Your response will give me space and a chance to calm down and get to some reason.
![]() |
Edward W. Hook M.D.
9 months ago
|
Welcome back to the Forum. I'm sorry you continue to struggle with your OCD. In preparing to respond, I reviewed some of the interactions that you have had with Dr. Handsfield and I over the past several years. I won't debate whether or not someone stuck you with a needle. Rather I will provide you with my reassurance that no one has ever been infected with HIV or other blood borne pathogens in the manner you describe. Further, I will tell you that is no blood was obviously present when you examined the site of the possible stick, there is NO RISK of infection. From a medical and scientific perspective there is no need for testing and no need for concern.
In your note you mention "...it has been hard to get a good therapist that you really connect with, without long wait lists and so on." I urge you continue in your efforts to connect with a trained mental health professional who can help you to address your concerns. Finding the right person is far, far more likely to be helpful than any scientific reassurance I can provide. Keep working to address your OCD.
I hope that, in the interim, my assurance that the situation you describe did not put you at risk for HIV. EWH
---
9 months ago
|
Dr. Hook, thank you very much. Just before you close this: can a person be seriously ( deeply) poked with a needle without feeling it? Just that , and I am done . I am asking because I looked at my arm only after I came home, so I am not sure if I bled or not ( although I saw no evidence of any bleeding, just a couple of tiny red dots that , again, may be just skin dots). Thank you much again, and that is it for me.
![]() |
Edward W. Hook M.D.
9 months ago
|
As Dr. Handsfield has told you in the past, In science we can never say never however it would be very, very unusual for you to be stuck deeply with a needle and not feel it. Try to address your OCD. EWH---
9 months ago
|
No need to test? Shall I just drop it and move on?
![]() |
Edward W. Hook M.D.
9 months ago
|
Correct. No need to test. My advice is to drop it and move forward.
This completes this thread. There shouldn’t be any need to return to the Forum.
---
9 months ago
|
I love the way you answered my last question, Dr. Hook. Thank you so very much , truly. You made me feel totally OK now.
![]() |
Edward W. Hook M.D.
9 months ago
|
I’m pleased that I could help. Take care. Closing the thread now. EWH---