[Question #12390] PrEP Usage and Delayed Result

Avatar photo
8 months ago
Good afternoon - thank you for remaining such a great resource for individuals who are trying to understand sexual health and break through stigma and misinformation.

I had previously requested more information (#12170) regarding the ability to trust HIV testing results after the window period. I keep seeing references to PrEP potentially delaying accurate results/seroconversion and I just wanted to ask the following: considering I am taking PrEP daily, can I trust the accuracy of HIV testing (a combination of Ab/p24 Ag, RNA, Real Time PCR, and antibody testing via finger prick and oral swab) after an eight-month period? My last test was two weeks ago (antigen/antibody) via a blood draw, and it returned as NEGATIVE. Is there the potential that my PrEP usage is still delaying seroconversion and, if so, at what point can I be confident in my results? 
Avatar photo
H. Hunter Handsfield, MD
8 months ago
Welcome back, but I'm sorry you found it necessary.

I'm not sure what you mean by "after an eight-month period". Do you mean 8 months continuing to take PrEP? Or have 8 months passed since stopping PrEP? If the latter, your test results conclusively prove you do not have HIV, assuming no sexual exposures during that time.

In theory, being on anti HIV drugs could delay HIV test results or make them falsely negative. However, this is believed to be rare. I am unaware of any reports of people who took PrEP regularly, got infected, had negative test results, and eventually tested positive after stopping PrEP drugs. I cannot say it doesn't happen, but if it does, it seems to be very rare. Of course this also depends on the nature of your sexual exposures while on PrEP. For example, if you have frequent unprotected anal sex with other men, you are at higher risk than with infrequent exposures, or with oral sex, mutual masturbation and so on. But even with the highest risk and frequency of exposure, PrEP is believed to be 99% effective. More likely it's 100%; I would suspect most apparent PrEP failures result from forgetting to take the medication(s) as recommended.

You should discuss this with the clinic or doctor who prescribed your PrEP; the chance is good that they have more experience in this situation than do I or Dr. Hook.

I hope these comments are helpful. Let me know if anything isn't clear.

HHH, MD
---
Avatar photo
8 months ago
My apologies for not being very clear - my previous question (#12170) had more context: in early April, the HIV test that I complete for my PrEP prescription came back as positive. I was told to immediately stop PrEP and to begin taking Dovato. I was also told come back for a “confirmation” test the very next day. This confirmation test (both “HIV Ab/p24 Ag screen” and "RNA, Real Time PCR”) came back as negative. I then stopped Dovato, and did not take any medication for a period of approximately two to three weeks. I was then re-tested (“HIV Ab/p24 Ag screen” and "RNA, Real Time PCR” and a comprehensive blood panel), and all tests came back as negative for HIV. At this time, I restarted my daily use of PrEP as my doctor stated he was "confident" that my vial had gotten mislabeled (he said that it had happened a few times before at their clinic). I have had repeated rapid tests (finger prick and oral) and laboratory tests (both “HIV Ab/p24 Ag screen” and "RNA, Real Time PCR”) performed nearly monthly since then and all have come back negative. I tested via lab draw ("Ab/p24 Ag screen") as recently as December 2nd, and this too returned as negative.

Since the doctor approved getting back on PrEP, I have been consistent with my daily usage. My concern, provided I've had no exposure since April, is whether or not I can have confidence in this most recent test as I do not know if PrEP could potentially still be delaying a positive result. Thank you!
Avatar photo
H. Hunter Handsfield, MD
8 months ago
I had read your discussion with Dr. Hook and was aware of your previous false positive test. I can't comment on your doctor's explanation, but a labeling error wasn't necessary responsible; false positive tests occur randomly from time to time. Anyway, this doesn't change my assessment. You can rely on your currently negative test results, both because PrEP is highly effective and because your test result probably is valid despite PEP. But as I also said, it would be reasonable for you to ask your doctor's opinion and advice about it.---
Avatar photo
8 months ago
Thank you - yes, I have visited with my doctor who explained he was confident in this latest result. Just wanted to do my due diligence and ask for a 2nd opinion. Thank you so much for your help, Doctor Handsfield. 
Avatar photo
H. Hunter Handsfield, MD
8 months ago
Thanks for the thanks; I'm glad to have helped. Happy holidays.---