If partner 1 has genital HSV-1 and partner 2 has oral HSV-1, is it possible for partner 2 to contract genital HSV-1 from partner 1 through unprotected sex?

That's a great question, Gordon.  In 33 years of practice I have only once seen someone who had an established history of cold sores acquire HSV 1 genitally subsequently.  I think the odds of either of you getting HSV 1 in a new place are extremely low and if I were in your situation, it would not at all be a worry for me.

Terri
---

Thank you for the response Terri,

I'm sorry but we have no statistics on that question.  I would guess it to be ess thlan 1%, if I had to take an educated guess
Terri
---

So if partner 1 has HPV-1 and partner 2 has nothing and they have unprotected oral sex, there is less than a 1% chance that partner 2 contracts oral HPV-1?

I think you mean HSV, not HPV, is that correct? 
Yes, that is a guess remember, OK?  There is no data on this topic

Terri
---