[Question #9234] Oral hpv risk
35 months ago
|
I contracted high risk HPV (either type 16 or 18) about 15 years ago. My immune system did not clear the infection naturally and I had a LEEP to remove the abnormal cells. I have been reading about oral HPV and cancer and am quite alarmed. I am wondering what the chances are that I have contracted oral HPV (type 16) and have a persistent infection given my history of not clearing the HPV naturally and what my chances are of having persistent HPV that will progress into cancer. I don’t drink or smoke and I am healthy otherwise. Given it takes 15 years to develop the cancer, I am on edge constantly that I have it and there’s nothing I can do this since there are no symptoms. Thank you for your help.
![]() |
H. Hunter Handsfield, MD
35 months ago
|
Welcome to the forum. Thanks for your confidence in our services.
The immune system almost always clears HPV eventually, at least to a point it cannot be detected with standard DNA testing. It often takes 2 years, sometimes several years. But it is likely your immune system indeed eradicate your HPV16 infection. (LEEP never eradicates HPV. It removes cells that have become pre-cancerous, but but plenty HPV is left behind for the immune system to deal with.) Could you have had oral/throat HPV16 infection at that time? Sure -- it's quite common, more so if you performed oral sex on the person from whom you acquired your cervical infection. However, oral HPV also is cleared by the immune system over time. It is unlikely you do not have detectable oral HPV16 at this time. That said, HPV can be suppressed by the immune system to a point the standard DNA tests do not detect it, and then recur. So I cannot say you are at zero risk for future development of throat cancer (or cervical or anal cancer) if your past HPV16 reactivates. But the chance of any of these is extremely low.
There's been a lot of media attention in recent years to pharyngeal (throat) cancer caused by HPV, and its frequency has been rising. But it remains an uncommon cancer -- a lot less frequent than breast, colon, lung, prostate, lymphoma, and other common cancers. Last I recall, there were around 16,000 cases per year in the entire US population. And millions of persons have had HPV16 (virtually the only HPV that causes pharyngeal cancer), and millions of those have had oral infection: so even among those with HPV16, throat cancer remains rare. (You can easily check statistics on this and all other cancers at the American Cancer society website (www.cancer.org).
For those reasons, your past history of precancerous cervical dysplasia due to HPV16 really doesn't mean you are at especially high risk for this fairly uncommon cancer. Perhaps a final word of reassurance is that pharyngeal cancer from HPV usually can effectively treated and cured.
It is not unreasonable to assure that when you have routine dental care, you ask the dentist to keep an eye out for any abnormalities in your pharynx. Or you could take it to an even higher level, and see an otolaryngologist (ENT specialist) for a careful examination every few years. But even without these measures, your risk is very low!
Finally, you can discuss HPV immunization with your primary care physician. Although the HPV vaccine initially was believed to have no effect on previously existing HPV infection, recent research has documented reduced rates of reactivation. Whether immunization would further lower your already low risk of HPV16 reactivation pharyngeal cancer isn't known -- but the vaccine is harmless and might add an additional measure of reassurance.
I hope these comments are helpful. Let me know if anything isn't clear.
HHH, MD
---
35 months ago
|
Thank you for this nuanced answer it is so reassuring. I wondered about this sentence, the double negative was a bit confusing:
“ It is unlikely you do not have detectable oral HPV16 at this time.”
Should this have read “it is unlikely you have detectable oral HPV at this time.”?
Also regarding the vaccine, I got gardisil 4 back in 2009 or so. Would there be any benefit to getting gardisil 9 now as a “booster” of sorts? I don’t think the cdc recommends that but I wonder if there is no harm then is that a reasonable choice to make?
Thank you again!
![]() |
H. Hunter Handsfield, MD
35 months ago
|
You correctly scoped out my typo. Sorry for any transient misunderstanding.
The need and value of boostering the HPV vaccines isn't really known. But after 14 years, I think it makes sense for you to speak with your doctor about having one dose of Gardasil-9, as an HPV16 booster. I would not recommend a 3 dose course, unless you are under 46 years old and your sexual lifestyle makes it likely you'll be exposed to the 5 HPV types covered by G-9 and not by G-4. If you're not "out there" (i.e. dating), I wouldn't recommend it.
---
35 months ago
|
Thank you again for this response. I have one more follow up before the thread is closed. I have read here that oral hpv is more difficult to contract and seems to clear faster than genital hpv as well - is that still the current understanding? I am trying to understand my risk but I can’t find any research on people with a history of cervical dysplasia and their future risk of oral cancer. Is there a correlation between the two? I know you said it’s an extremely low risk still but trying to quantify my personal risk given my medical history. Thanks again.
![]() |
H. Hunter Handsfield, MD
35 months ago
|
Oral HPV infections are around one fifth the frequency of genital infection; it is likely that most or all genital HPV types are less able to infect the oral cavity than genital or anal areas. I am unaware of data that oral HPV is cleared any more rapidly. I also am unaware of of any studies on the specific question you ask, i.e. the frequency of pharyngeal cancer due to HPV (or oral HPV infection) in women who have (or have had) cervical dysplasia. But I would be surprised if there is any significant difference compared with women who have not had cervical dysplasia.
In terms of your own risk of pharyngeal cancer due to HPV, I would just repeat one of my points above: there are millions of people in the US who have had oral HPV16 and only ~16,000 such cancers per year, with no evidence that those who have had cervical dysplasia have any higher risk than others. You can do the rough math -- obviously the risk is low. Also, it's generally an easily treatable cancer, without disfiguring surgery. The death rate from pharyngeal HPV cancer is low compared with other common cancers.
That concludes this thread. I'm glad the discussion has apparently been helpful. If you are still happy with our services, would you consider making a tax deductible charitable donation to ASHA, the forum sponsor? ASHA is the nation's top nonprofit organization in support of sexual health, especially in relation to STIs. There is a donate link at www.ashasexualhealth.org.
Best wishes and stay safe.
---